The War on Terror Behind Bars

The War on Terror has reshaped the U.S. prison system by increasing the incarceration of Muslims and altering how Muslim prisoners are treated once behind bars, with national security invoked as a justification. In the aftermath of  9/11, the United States primarily adopted a zero-tolerance, preventative counterterrorism strategy aimed at incapacitating anyone suspected of supporting terrorist organizations before an attack could occur.1 The resulting rise in Muslim incarceration was driven largely by expanded surveillance and informant-based sting operations.2 To make this preventative model possible, the government created new laws and policies, such as federal terrorism statutes and the broadening of the Sentencing Guidelines Terrorism Enhancement, that allowed law enforcement officials to arrest individuals well before they could commit or support violent acts and then sentence them to lengthy prison terms.3 

The USA PATRIOT Act broadened the Terrorism Enhancement further, allowing it to apply to categories of terrorism-related offenses, including: “1) crimes involving terrorism, but not falling within the statutory definition of ‘federal crime of terrorism’; 2) obstructing an investigation of a federal crime of terrorism; 3) harboring or concealing a terrorist; and 4) intending to influence the government’s conduct by intimidation or coercion, retaliate against government conduct, or influence a civilian population by intimidation or coercion”.4  Because the Terrorism Enhancement applies to inchoate offenses as well, defendants who conspire or attempt to commit a crime are viewed the same as those who actually commit the crime, even though Sentencing Guidelines typically reduce the offense level for uncompleted crimes.5 Regardless of the extent of the conduct, whether it be material support or actual terroristic acts or attempts, the enhancement remains the same.6  These policies promote the idea that those who are convicted of terrorism-related crimes cannot be rehabilitated or deterred, which is used to justify lengthy sentences.7  

As Muslims have been disproportionately prosecuted in the War on Terror, the treatment of Muslims inside prisons has worsened.8 Prior to the War on Terror, Muslims had already faced oppression by prison officials.9 Muslim prisoners were put in solitary, given extra-legal punishments, and denied access to religious leaders and texts.10 After 9/11, prison administrations reframed their tactics with an anti-terrorism framework to treat Muslims as a special threat.11 

  One tactic used to restrict Muslims’ ability to practice their faith is the Standardized Chapel Library Project, instituted in 2007.12 This project sought to inventory all chapel books to determine their permissibility under the new security policies which resulted in books being deemed inappropriate and removed from the Muslim library.13 Muslim literature was treated as a threat that was capable of inciting violent extremism.14 Access to spiritual guidance was further narrowed when imams were barred from entering federal prisons based on the perception that leaders from the outside world could act as extreme influences that would incite or radicalize Muslims behind bars.15  

The War on Terror has both funneled more Muslims into the prison system and made the incarceration itself more hostile. This issue is particularly concerning given the existing isolation of incarcerated Muslims from Muslims on the outside. It is imperative that the Muslim community fights against the policies that result in the disproportionate incarceration of Muslims, and that we do our part as individuals to ensure that incarcerated Muslims are able to practice their faith. 

Janna Zabaik
National Security Criminal Defense Center (NSCDC) Fellow, Georgetown Justice Fellow