National Security Criminal Defense Center (NSCDC)
The Issue
The government uses FBI undercover operations to entrap Muslim Americans by inducing criminal activity when someone is not predisposed to commit the offense. See Matthews v. United States, 485 U.S. 58, 63 (1988).
This leads to arrests, prosecutions, and harsh sentencings in situations where there may not have ever been a crime absent the actions of undercover informants. Critically, the emphasis on predisposition at trial permits jurors to act on their implicit or explicit biases against Muslims as presumptive terrorists based on religious identity and unpopular political beliefs. See JOHN SIDES & DALIA MOGAHED, DEMOCRACY FUND VOTER STUDY GRP., MUSLIMS IN AMERICA: PUBLIC PERCEPTIONS IN THE TRUMP ERA 9 fig.3 (2018), www.voterstudygroup.org/ publication/muslims-in-america [https://perma.cc/4UL9-XKH5].
To fight back, our team utilizes specialized knowledge to identify patterns of abuse when challenging evidence gathered through informants. Despite the average defendant posing no risk to the safety of the undercover informant, the government seeks to withhold most information concerning the undercover informant and prevent cross-examination on any areas touching their expertise or background. Additionally, the government routinely seeks to close the courtroom during their testimony and have the undercover testify either in disguise or from behind a screen. These measures prejudice the defendant by both limiting their ability to confront the evidence against them and creating an atmosphere of fear in the courtroom. MLFA attorneys have experience in litigating, the scope of discovery and cross examination, combatting the prejudicial aspects of the manner in which their testimony is delivered. Effectively confronting the undercover operative is critical not just to success of a trial, but is demonstrated in recent cases (e.g., United States vs. Fong & United States vs. Giampietro) in reaching favorable settlements.
Cases
United States v. Khaled Miah
MLFA’s Criminal Defense Department represented Mr. Miah in his criminal jury trial in the Western District of Pennsylvania in December of 2021.
United States v. Imad Eddin Wadi
MLFA’s Criminal Defense Department is currently working on appealing Mr. Wadi’s convictions to the Fifth Circuit in hopes of correcting the grave injustice inflicted upon Mr. Wadi and his family.
Other Resources
United States v. Jason Fong
ALL MATERIAL SUPPORT CHARGES DISMISSED! Mr. Fong was targeted by FBI counterterrorism undercover online operatives who sought to persuade Mr. Fong to commit a crime.
Other Resources
United States v. Georgianna Giampietro
A mother of two in Tennessee, who converted to Islam in 2014, initially supported ISIS but later distanced herself as their actions became more extreme.
Other Resources
News & Commentary
United States v. Khaled Miah
- Upholding the First Amendment Rights
- MLFA argued Important First Amendment Case at Third Circuit Court of Appeals – MLFA
United States v. Georgianna Giampietro
United States v. Jason Fong
- A Revert’s Fight against Discriminatory Prosecution
- MLFA’s Landmark Dismissal: Challenging Material Support of Terrorism Charges