CLCMA has been working with Mr. M. for over four years. We prepared for the day when Mr. M.’s oldest son would turn 21 and be able to file a family-based Petition for Alien Relative for him, which came to fruition in June 2020. Along with the application for permanent residence, CLCMA challenged USCIS’s prior arbitrary determination through the submission of a legal brief explaining the misapplication of the law in Mr. M.’s case. This legal brief also requested the Department of Homeland Security waive the inadmissibility determination, which should never have been applied to his case. USCIS conducted its initial interview in July 2021, but was unable to make a final decision at that time.
CLCMA and Mr. M. are hopeful for a successful resolution at the administrative level, which would bring closure to a journey that has spanned three decades to make the U.S. his permanent home. However, CLCMA believes that Mr. M.’s case provides a valuable opportunity for impact litigation in federal court to challenge the government’s use of the Tier III designation to discriminate against Muslim applicants for immigration benefits should USCIS deny this application.